Wednesday, 30 May 2012

Wednesday May 30, 2012


Wednesday May, 30 2012

Intentions of the Treaties Parties

Vested Treaty Governance – the treaties somehow recognized the inherent authority of the first nations to govern themselves and to retain their own sovereignty.

TREATIES RECOGNIZE INHERENT SOVEREIGNTY AND RIGHT OF SELF GOVERNMENT OF ABORIGINAL NATIONS.

Ambiguity- both parties may be right depending on their interpretation of the agreement.


Spirit and Intent
·         Treaties need to be honoured in accordance with their spirit and intent
·         Treaties cannot be interpreted solely based on the words in the written text
·         The treaties were written by the government agents in accordance with their understanding of the treaties
·         We have seen that the understanding of the First Nations of the spirit and intent of the treaties was somewhat different than that of government.
 

Contra Proferentem (RULE)
*if there are 2 possible interpretations, the government must go with the interpretation that is more favourable towards the aboriginal, because it was the government that drew up the document*
This rule only applies if there is an ambiguity
·         There is a rule of interpretation of contractual documents which is based on the idea that a document will be strictly interpreted against the party who wrote the document
·         This is based on the assumption that the party who draws up the document is in the best position to protect their own interest
·         The other party has three options, sign it as written, ask for amendment or don’t sign

Deal or no Deal?
·         First Nations entering into a treaty had to rely on someone else telling them what the Crown was offering, and to tell the Crown what they were agreeing to.
·         Literal translation does not always capture the precise meaning of the ideas being expressed as they are understood by the speaker. *because of culture and context*

Who’s interpretation
·         The general understanding of government was that the treaties were a surrender of land, a real estate transaction
·         First nations understood the treaties differently
·         The First Nations understanding is reflected in the Elders understanding of the spirit and intent of the treaties

Treaty Principals
·         The treaty is a recognized by the Crown of the Fist Nations Relationship with the creator
·         The treaty is intended to maintain peace between the parties
·         The treaty is an agreement to maintain good relations of a kinship of nature
·         The treaty guaranteed survival and stability based on mutual sharing
·         Mutual sharing includes the First Nations right to a continued livelihood

Living together on the land
·         Canada entered into treaties to obtain use of the First nation lands
·         The understanding of First Nations elders is that land was to be shared, by not that they were giving up ownership and control
Ø  Treaty nations did not agree to extinguish of aboriginal rights and title
Ø  Treat nations intended to share the territory and jurisdiction

Flexibility and adaptability
·         Treaties were seen by 1st nations as guarantees of their liberty, independence and self-sufficiency
·         In a modern context this required that the treaty be adapted to modern circumstances
·         What remains constant is the relationship to the land.

Economic participation
·         The treaty was seen as a promise of assistance in participation in the new economies that would emerge as a consequence of the settlement and development by the newcomers
·         The intent was that the 1st nations would remain self-reliant in the new environment
Education
·         The promise of schools was seen as providing a means for 1ast nations people to obtain the necessary skills to participate in the new economies
·         That education must evolve to become appropriate to current needs, while being directed by the 1st nations themselves.
                                                                                                                                                  
Governance
·         Treaties were negotiated on a nation to nation basis
·         1st nations seek to develop governance structures that have legitimacy in the eyes of their citizens and are culturally appropriated
·         At the same time those structures must be flexible enough to accommodate the evolving needs of 1st nation’s communities.


The Government’s View
·         Based primarily on written text within the context of Canadian law and polcy
·         The differences in interpretation are largely due to the policies adopted by government in respect of 1st Nations
Ø  Protection-Royal Proclamation
Ø  Paternalism-status as wards of the Crown
Ø  Assimilation- Indian Act

Fundamental assumptions
·         The Crown assumed it has sovereignty over 1st nations territories
·         The crown assumed it had power to extend its laws to 1st nations
·         The crown assumed the superiority of its civilization and religious beliefs.

Royal Proclamation
·         Developed so that the crown could acquire first nation lands through the treaty process (sees the treaty process as a way to acquire land)

Indian Policy and Indian Act
·         Crown assumed first nations would disappear into society

Good and Loyal Subjects
·         Invariably the treat texts include provisions whereby the Indians agree to abide by and obey the law and to become good and loyal subjects of Her Majesty
·         Once again this is at odds with the 1st nations perspectives in which they would continue to have jurisdiction in the territories and have their political systems preserves.






Vested Treaty Governance
Vested- secure in the possession of or assigned to a person... Protected or established by law or contract

Pre-existing Sovereignty
·         Aboriginal sovereignty and governance exist because First Nations had their own confederated civilization prior to treaties with the Crown
·         This was characterized by distinct governance laws and economies.

Treaties with the Crown
·         Were an attempt to conciliate pre-existing aboriginal sovereignty with the assumed sovereignty of the crown
·         This gave rise to unique agreements that engaged the sovereignty of both parties
·         Pre-existing aboriginal governance was ‘vested’ in the British constitutional law ie: the rights was recognized
·         The created a federal relationship in which the respective author of each of the parties was recognized.

  Why Enter into a Treaty?
·         First Nations: Maintain aboriginal sovereignty and governance over shared territory and peoples
·         Crown: gain access to land and resources
·         The fact that an agreement is sought implies recognition of the authority of the other party to enter into such an agreement
·         The Crown claim to sovereignty does not negate the pre-existing Aboriginal Sovereignty

Sui Generis
·         Means Unique
·         Treaties are not like any other agreements and are based off unique circumstances

Perspectives on treaties
·         The distinct views of the parties as to the nature and effect of a ‘treaty’ is a product of their world views
·         What is a common is that the treaty agreements would define rights and obligations of the respective parties
·         This of necessity includes consensual reconciliations of differing views, as well as a mutual recognition of the authorities of the other
·         It is not a wholesale surrender of author to the British crown where aboriginal peoples are concerned.
Or does it?
·         The ‘good and loyal subject’ clause on the face of it seems to confer sovereignty on the Crown
·         Taken together with the ‘yield, cede, surrender and release to the Government and the Dominion of Canada, for Her Majesty the Queen, and Her successors forever, all their rights, titles and privileges whatsoever, to the lands included within the following limits, that is to say it is not an entirely unreasonable interpretation that the aboriginal partied were deferring to the author of the crown.

An alternative view
·         Henderson argues that the ‘good and loyal subject’ in fact affirms the aboriginal sovereignty and governance
·         He argues that the undertaking by the chiefs and headmen is in fact a recognition of their continued authority
·         Note however that he, in somewhat facile manner, states that this was so obvious that ‘little discussion of... them by the treaties parties exist’
·         Is this because it was indeed ‘obvious’? As critical thinkers we need to be cautious of supporting our assumptions by stating that something is ‘obvious’ particularly when there are other possible interpretations.

QUESTION OF THE DAY!
In Chapter 2 Sakej Henderson argues that the treaties recognize the sovereignty and authority of First Nations. Summarize the arguments and that he uses to support this assertion? What arguments can be put forward to the contrary.

No comments:

Post a Comment