Tuesday, 29 May 2012

Tuesday May 29, 2012

Tuesday May 29, 2012
Contemporary Aboriginal Self Government
When the federal and provincial governments patriated in the constitution in 1982 the pressure applied by the aboriginal peoples resulted in the inclusion of a clause which was intended to protect aboriginal rights.

Constitute Act 1982
(1)   The existing aboriginal and treaty right of the aboriginal peoples of Canada are hereby recognized and affirmed.
(2)   Aboriginal people of Canada are the Indian, Inuit and Metis
(3)   For greater certainty in subsection 1 treaty rights includes rights that now exist by way of land claims agreements or may be so acquired.

·         Self government is a inherent aboriginal right
·         This has been emphatically state by aboriginal leaders
·         It has also been adopted as a matter of policy by the federal government since 1995
·         The problem is that there is as yet no fundamental agreement on how that right is to be exercise
·         The debate has two extremes with a broad spectrum in between

A.    Self government is desirable but must be manifested within the framework of the existing governmental order (third order government)
B.     As an inherent right self government must be developed in accordance with the will of the aboriginal nations seeking to exercise that right irrespective of the interest of Federal and provincial governments.

·         The issue is  complicated by the fact that aboriginal governments would of necessity exercise jurisdiction in the same territory in which the federal and provincial governments exercise their jurisdiction
·         One view is that any limitation on the exercise of jurisdiction by aboriginal governments is an infringement of the aboriginal right and therefore indefensible
·         The other view is that aboriginal governments and the federal and provincial governments must find ways of exercising their jurisdictions co-operatively.

History
·         Global decolonization (imperial powers declare rights of power)
·         Un declaration on human rights
·         Indian Act Amendments (1951 significant amendments eg. Let woman vote in band council elections)
·         The right to vote without enfranchisement (1960, now you can vote without giving up Indian status)
·         Hawthorn- Tremblay
·         The ‘White Paper (1969)
·         FSIN “Indian Government (1977) published a paper called Indian government, raise the idea that first nations have sovereignty.
·         (1982) the recognition of aboriginal rights in the constitution
·         The Penner Report
·         The Constitutional Conferences(1983,1984,1985, 1987)
·         The royal commission on Aboriginal Peoples
·         The UN Declaration on the rights of indigenous people.

Human Rights
·         The creation of the united nations provided an opportunity for these new states to press the political agenda of human rights
·         Part of that discourse dealt with the right of religious, social and cultural minorities within the states
·         The universal declaration of human rights was proclaimed on December 10, 1948

Right to participate in Government
·         Article 21
·         (1) Everyone has the right to take part in the government of his country, directly or through freely chosen representatives.
·         (2) Everyone has the right of equal access to public service in his country.
·         (3) The will of the people shall be the basis of the authority of government, this will shall be expressed in periodic and genuine elections which shall be by universal and equal suffrage and shall be held by secret vote equivalent free voting procedures.

Time for a Change
·         As a member of the United Nations and a party to the Universal declaration of Human Right it was clear that Canada has to amend its policies with respect to aboriginal peoples
·         At the same time aboriginal leaders were inspired by the struggles of other indigenous people and minorities around the globe because more active in pressing for such change.

1951 Indian Act Amendments
·         A Series of amendments to the Indian Act in 1951 opened the door to greater political activity by Indians in Canada
·          From 1921 the Indian act had banned the raising of funds for Indian political organization, which were primarily interested in pursuing land and treaty rights claims. These prohibitions were removed in 1951.

Universal Suffrage
·         Registered Indians in Canada did not have the right to vote in the Federal Elections until 1960!
·         Political participation by register Indians was limited to voting in band councils elections
·         The band councils so elected has only the legislative power conferred on them by the Indian Act.

Hawthorn- Tremblay
·         Partly as a result of the pressure from the aboriginal groups such as the national Indian council the federal government constituted the Hawthorn-Tremblay commission
·         The mandate of this commission was to investigate social and economic conditions in native communities and to make commendations for changed.






Citizen Plus
·         The Hawthorn Tremblay report rejected the policy of the assimilation which has been pursued by the Canadian government since 1867
·         The report recommended that Indians be recognized as citizen of Canada by with recognition of the aboriginal and treaty rights.
·         The report also made recommendation to the government to encourage the development of “Indian local government”

Hawthorn Rejected
·         The Trudeau Government did not favour the Hawthorn recommendations and responded with “a statement of the government of Canada on Indian Policy’ (The white Paper) proposing repeal of the Indian act
·         The policy favoured in the white paper was one of the integration of Indians in Canadian society without special right or statuses
·         Indian lands would be transferred to Indian control and be administered by local governments similar to municipal governments.

The Natives Get Restless
·         The response to the white paper by Indian leaders was swift and uncompromising
·         The repeal of the Indian act was seen as being the loss of treaty and aboriginal rights
·          The Indian response was in the form of a document entitles “citizens plus” which has become known as the red paper the basis of the Indian repose was that no policy which did not recognizer treat and aboriginal rights.

Reprieve
·         The Trudeau government was caught off guard by the Indian response and formally withdrew the policy proposals contained in the White Paper
·         The government however began to co-opt native organizations by funding them, ostensibly as part of the broader social policy of multiculturalism.

Indian Government
·         The Federation of the Saskatchewan Indians paper entitled “Indian Government” 1977 was the next major event
·         This document asserted the continued sovereignty of Indian nations
·         The scope of the power of the Federal Government in the Constitution Act of 1867 was limited to the regulating relations with Indian nations by not control over their internal affairs.

More Indian Government
·         Indian government powers have been wrongfully suppressed and eroded by the Canadian Government
·         The scope of Indian government jurisdiction is broader than that delegated to band councils by the Indian Act.
·         The relationship between the Canadian governments and Indian government is defined by the treaties which reserve to Indian governments the right of self government and control of Indian lands and resources.


Constitutional Recognition
·         Face with the determined response of Indian leaders, and wishing to pursue his agenda of constitutional amendment, Trudeau included in those constitutional amended the provision s off the s.35
·         At the same time he established a parliamentary committee to look into aboriginal government.

Penner report
·         so named after the chairman, the Penner report supported the inclusion of aboriginal government as the third order’ of government within the constitutional framework
·         the report also defined areas of jurisdiction for this government as including education, child welfare, health care, membership, social and cultural development, land and resource use, revenue raising, economic and commercial development justice and law enforcement and inter governmental relations.

Stalemate!
·         Alas the Penner report found little favour with the government, beyond a vague agreement that indeed there was a right to self government by that it had to be exercised within the framework of the Canadian constitution
·         The last half of the 1980’s saw a series of negotiations between government and what were now known as First Nations in an effort to define the nature and scope of that right.

RCAP
·         Continuing dissatisfaction with the progress made following the constitutional recognition of aboriginal rights erupted into confrontations in the early 1990s
·         Governments response was to create a royal commission
·         This commission released its report in 1996
·         The RCAP report made it clear that no further constitutional amendment was required in respect of Aboriginal self government
·         It stated that self government was a right vested in aboriginal nations, not ‘bands’ as defined in the Indian Act: a sizeable body of Aboriginal people with a shared sense of national identity that constitutes the predominant population of a certain territory.

Jurisdiction
·         What is (will be?) the nature and extent of the author of aboriginal governments
·         RCAP saw the authority as comprising two dimensions: core jurisdiction and peripheral jurisdiction
·         The boundaries between these jurisdictions had become the subject of negotiation between aboriginal nations and federal and provincial governments.



 



Federal Policy
·         The federal government conceded that aboriginal self government was indeed an inherent right and as such entitled to recognition and affirmation
·         Self-Government: Negotiated arrangements that give Aboriginal people greater control over their own affairs, in areas such as health care, child welfare, education, housing, and economic development. The government of Canada recognized that aboriginal peoples have an inherent right of self-government and has committed to negotiating self-government agreements with aboriginal peoples.

United Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples
·         More recently in UN Declaration on the rights of indigenous peoples has also brought pressure to bear on the Canadian Government to advance the debate
·         Canada initially declined to endorse the declaration but ultimately did so in November 2009

 
QUESTION OF THE DAY!
In class today we considered Chapter 1 “Reconciling Solitudes” In this Chapter the author looks at the scope of this idea of Aboriginal self-government. The idea was described as a spectrum with extremes at either end and various shades in between. Briefly give an overview of that spectrum. What are the extremes, what are the shades in between and what are the underlying assumptions on which they are based?


No comments:

Post a Comment