Tuesday, 19 June 2012

Wednesday June 19, 2012


Wednesday June 19, 2012

West Bank First Nation Self Government Agreement
Federal Province
Jurisdiction
Jurisdiction
             
Eg. Admin of justice
Court System
No Red ties on Tuesday
·         Not an area of jurisdiction that conflicts with the federal government..


BUT THENNN......
YOU MUST WEAR RED TIES ON TUESDAY :O
ß So that law is cancelled out...!




   

West Bank first nation self government agreement
West bank first nation self government ACT (FED)

FEDERAL LAW
Taxation- Westbank First Nation
Tax Rate 30%
Income Tax Act (federal law)
TAX Rate 35%






S88 Indian Act
Provincial law of general application applies to Indians in the province
Some Exceptions: Subject to any treaty right


Lands
Control of land/ land management
·         Legal title to First Nation lands is held by the crown
·         Beneficial interest is held by the First nations collective

Indian Act
West Bank First Nation Land Rules
-Crown holds title for WFN
-Band council allots possession subject to ministers approval
-May receive certification of possession
Crown holds title for WFN
-land is allotted to individual members by the council <no ministerial approval needed>
-Have created a land registry
-land can be bought and sold but only to other members or back to the West bank First Nation

Monday June 18,2012


Monday June 18,2012
Constitution
Structures and procedures of government    
-a foundation of all the other things that a government does... spells out all the particulars of what is supporting the structure...

The Foundation of Governmental Authority.

Paramount Law
·         all laws must fit under the parameters of the constitution
·         All laws made by government must comply with the constitution    
·         Laws that don’t apply are non constitutional

Constitution shall provide for
·         Authority of the Council
Ø  Acts on the Behalf of WFN
Ø  Democratic election of council members by the W.F.N members.

Democratic- reflects the will of the members.

-Could Democratic elections be based on representatives selected by families or clans?
-Financial Management and Accountability rules
-Conflict of Interest rules

E) Procedures for passage and amendment of laws
G) Amending procedures for the constitution
·         Eg. Constitutional amendment may require more than a bare majority vote..

The Westbank First Nation agreement is not definitive of the inherent rights of self government.
It follows that constitutional amendments will be needed in the future
The Consitution required by the agreement is limited

Wednesday, 13 June 2012

Tuesday June 12, 2012


Tuesday June 12, 2012

Self Determinationà Manifested in self government (institutions and processes through with self determination is exercise.

Self Governmentà Vaguey Defined.. institutions and processes which (increase self determining capacity)


Negotiation
·         Canada and the provinces will negotiate with aboriginal nations with respect to self government.
·         Some issues are not open for negotiation (Canadian citizenship, criminal law, national defences, foreign relations)
·         This poses a question... What jurisdiction is Canada willing to negotiate on?...
·         fairly broad range of jurisdictions.
·         Generally the areas of greatest significance to the aboriginal nation
·         Matters that affect them most directly.

From the point of view of aboriginal nations the exercise of self government has become a pragmatic question
·         Take what we can get rather than waiting to get all that we want at once.


Jurisdiction
Who has the authority???
With respect to:
·         Health, education, land and resource management, language and culture, administration of justice

How do those authorities interact?

FEDERAL
 PROVINCIAL
ABORIGINAL
Fisheries
Resource management
Harvesting rights
Environment
Environment
environment

CFS
CFS
Health for FN
Health for Prov. Residents
HEALTH




Core Jurisdiction: Exclusive to aboriginal nation eg. Membership
Shared Jurisdiction: of concern to 2 or more levels of government eg. Environmental , labour standards.

Monday, 11 June 2012

Monday June 11, 2012


Monday June 11, 2012

àProcess, not a single event
àAspirational not definitive or mandatory
à Diversity-
à First Nations want to be free from Indian act
àSelf government reflects local circumstances
            -Non Member Populations
            -jurisdiction of FCD/Prov/Local Govt
àFinalization can be difficult
àGovernments have shown flexibility in drafting and implementing agreements

First Nations with outstanding land claims (aboriginal title has not been surrendered)
First nations with treaties  (aboriginal titles has been surrendered)
*LAND CLAIM STILL OUTSTANDING
*IF YOU SETTLE LAND CLAIMS YOU MOVE TO THIS CATAGORY

Land Claim Settled
Constitution act treaty rights include rights arising from land claims settlement.

  
Aboriginal Rights
Treaty Rights
Self governments that agreements that are not part of a land claim settlement are aboriginal rights but not treaty rights
Self government agreements that are part of a land claim settlement become treaty rights

Panacea to reality
è Discussions has center upon theoretical aspects of self government
è Various self government arrangements have been initiated
è We will undertake an examination of some of these to see what is happening

Models for self government
è We have seen the theoretical basis for Aboriginal self government: ie the consent of the governed to the authority of the governing institution
è We have seen how governance was imposed on First nations without their consent and participation
è We have seen that First nations have attempted to reassert their right to be self governing
è Vigorous discussion of these issues has characterizes the past three decades, yet the question remains what if anything has resulted from these talks.
è The cynical observer would be quick to respond little, if anything, however certain events can be identified as indicating some progress

Land claims and settlements
è In 1970 the Supreme Court of Canada, in its decision in the case of Calder VS A.G for British Columbia signalled a turning point when it recognized the legal validly of Aboriginal Title.
è This was reflected in the conclusion of the James Bay and Northern Quebec Agreements in which the Cree and Inuit of Northern Quebec forced the provincial government to negotiate a land claims settlement as a condition of permitting the construction of two major hydro projects.

NISGAA Final Settlement Agreement
·         Negotiations for the settlement of the Nisgaa land claim began in the 1970s after the Calder decision
·         The opportunity to initiate the process arose from the need of the government of Canada to settle the land claims
·         The Nisgaa view was that they did not want to be merely another group of reserves subject to the Indian act.
Nisgaa lismims government
·         The Nisgaa had been situated on four reserves that comprised the communities in which they resided
·         With the land claim settlement came the addition of a significant area of land
·         To obtain the maximum benefit for this the Nisgaa needed a degree of control over that territory not available to them if they were reserves as defined in the Indian act
·         In short they need to have control over the land and resources.
*NISGAA WANTED CONTROL OF MEMBERSHIP

The Solution
·         The solution decided upon was the removal of the Nisgaa ‘bands’ from the Indian Act
·         This was done by creating the Nisgaa Lisims government consisting of the 4 village governments and urban ‘locals’ comprised of con resident members
·         This government has a broad range of powers to the legislate.


Jurisdictions
·         Language/culture
·         Resource management
·         Marriage
·         Emergency services
·         Health
·         Transportation
·         Child welfare
·         Education

Cold assume jurisdictions that had been agreed upon but it was NOT MANDATORY
Existing jurisdiction of fed/provincial jurisdictions would continue until Nisgaa lisims decided to exercise their jurisdiction

Nationhood- Transcends territorial boundaries, limited by de facto sovereignty in areas of jurisdictions agreed upon
  
Self Government Agreements
·         In the 1990’s federal and provincial governments entered in to land settlements with various first nations in British Columbia, the Yukon and the NWT which included the creation of aborigina governments with inherent authority to make law within their territories

Community cooperations
·         Within the Northern Quebec agreements the land which was retained by the Cree and Inuit was to be governed not by ‘band councils’ but by a form of local government taking the form of community corporations
·         In additions to the compensation which these government received for the surrender of their land they would also share in the resource and development revenues from the surrendered lands

Jurisdiction Includes local government and administration of settlement lands and revenues
Limited legislative jurisdiction

Nunavut
Community corporations sent Reps to a regional body- Nunavut regional corp...
The territorial government of Nunavut is separate from the settlement agreement but the inuit are guaranteed proportional representation in the territorial government

Question of the Day!
what are 3 essential characteristics of aboriginal self government in Canada

Wednesday, 6 June 2012

Wednesday June 6, 2012


Wednesday June 6, 2012

Governance
Government
Dictionary says....
The action or manner of governing: a more responsive system of governance will be required.
Dictionary says....
The system by which a nation state or community is governed

CHAPTER 4 says....
A prescribed framework that establishes a relationship between rules and the ruled.
The institutional expression of governance
What institutions and processes are created to carry out the act of governing
The form of the relationship between ruler and ruled

Absolutism
Arbitrary decision making by someone with the means to enforce those decisions

Consensus based decision making- made by those directly affected

Aboriginal self government has a means as indigenous people’s exercise their right to self determination, what it actually looks like is less important than if it actually works or not.

The political processes
·         The aboriginal self government debate in Canada has moved from whether it is an inherent aboriginal right to how that right will be exercised
·         It is in this discussion that the definition of governance that the framework articulated by Fleras and Maake of central importance.

 Multiple manifestations
The essence of self determination is found in the participation by aboriginal peoples in the process of governance. That process can take many different forms

1.      Statehood
Ø  Legally recognized sovereignty
Ø  Internal and external autonomy(Independence)
Ø  No external interference
2.      Nationhood
Ø  De Facto Sovereignty
Ø  Control over multiple but interlocking jurisdictions within the existing nation state
3.      Community Hood
Ø  Functional sovereignty
Ø  Autonomy within the community
Ø  Control over internal jurisdictions but may be limited by interactions with similar bodies or higher political authorities

4.      Institutional
Ø  Nominal sovereignty
Ø  Decision making power through institutional inclusion
Ø  Creates parallel structures