Thursday, 31 May 2012

Thursday May 31, 2012


Thursday May 31, 2012

1st Week Test

So what really happened?
·         Intriguing as Henderson’s argument is, it is offered after the fact
·         The ‘fact’ in this case being that the Aboriginal right of self government has been observed in the breach rather than the observance
·         In the RCAP report a number of assertions were made with respect to the historical reality

What Canada did
·         Ignored, failed to fulfil and replaced Treaty governance with false assumptions and abuse power and law
Ø  Assumed the inferiority of, and the incapacity to be self governing, of aboriginal nations
Ø  Viewed treaties as political expedients rather than as obligations
Ø  Treated first nations as wards of the states and made decisions for their ‘benefit’ without consulting them
 
Treaty Governance?
·         The effect of government action was to usurp the Aboriginal nations rights under the treaties
·         Henderson argues that the honouring of the treaty governance is the way forward for aboriginal self government
·         As such aboriginal self government must be seen as a co-operative venture in which aboriginal nations take their place in a consensual exercise of governmental powers that includes them as well as other Canadians
·         Not everyone would agree but it is an attractive government

SEGREGATIONIST                                               INTEGRATIONIST (Henderson)
 
Aboriginal Rights
Definition- Practises...traditions....customs...integral to their distinctive cultures


QUEEN (Supreme court of Canada) VS Van DerPeet (1996)
Ms Van Der Peet had caught lots of FISH ... she was able to do this because it was her aboriginal fishing right... but then she took the FISH  and sold them... for $$$
Conclusion was that her claimed right to sell fish was thrown out because it wasn’t distinctive for their culture to sell the fish.
 

R(Queen)  Versus Gladstone (1996)
Mr Gladstone and his friends.... sold FISH EGGS... huge market for this! Mr. Gladstone was part of the Heiltskuki in British Columbia... but this turned out different then that VanDer Peet case because looking back in history, this culture used to trade and sell FISH EGGS (roe) before the Europeans came.

R(Queen) VS Sparrow (1990)
Federal regulations say that you could only fish with net that is 25 Fathoms long.. but Sparrow always used 40 fathoms.
Somewhere between 1982 and 1985 there was a change of how many fathoms you could fish with (from 75 to 25 fathoms)
But Sparrow said with the constitution when it recognized aboriginal rights the length of fathoms allowable was 75. So therefore sparrow was allowed to continue his right to fish with his 40 fathoms.

Infringement
Supreme Court ended up saying that Aboriginal rights can be infringed upon... but they can only infringe on a aboriginal right if they could justify that infringement.

Justification exist...
a)      Where there is a very good reason to limit an aboriginal right (conservation...public safety...economic development)
b)      Consideration must be given to the aboriginal rights (impacts on the rights...
c)      Consultation with aboriginal nations
d)     Compensation for loss 

Question of the Day!
Summarize the respective views of the Segregationist and Integrationist Positions.



No comments:

Post a Comment