Tuesday June 5,
2012
Contesting
Indigenous Peoples Governance
The politics of
State Determination vs. Self- Determining Autonomy
The short story
·
In
1995 the government of Canada stated in its inherent rights policy that self
government as an inherent right within the meaning of the s.35 of the
constitution act of 1982
·
This
policy falls short in that it acknowledges the nature of the right but does not
deal with the scope of the right.
·
Inherent
rights can be negotiated however, but never has when it comes to the issue of
sovereignty, and sovereignty overruled any inherent rights.
The View from
the other end
·
If
self government is indeed an inherent right then the scope of that right is
broader than the limited version recognized in the inherent rights policy
·
Self
government cannot be severed from self determination if it is to be anything
more than an exercise of delegate
Treaties
·
Treaties
were recognized by the colonizers as a means of regulating relations between
sovereign entities
·
European
powers had used treaties between themselves for several centuries to establish
alliances and to terminate conflicts
·
Agreements
for these purposes were also made between aboriginal nations
If it ain’t
broke
·
It
is hardly surprising that after discovering America the colonizing powers and
the indigenous populations entered into treaties, a mechanism with which both
parties were familiar
·
By
entering into a treaty is the promise that each of the parties have the
capacity or authority to do so.
Sovereignty
·
Self
Ruling
·
Not
subject to some other political authority
Self
determination
·
Self
determination is a somewhat different concept from sovereignty
·
Self-determination
flows from sovereignty
·
It
is the power of a sovereign entity to make decisions about how sovereignty will
be exercised (Process)
Self
government
·
The
details of the exercise of authority
The
International covenant on civil and political rights
Article 1: All peoples have the right to self
determination
·
Freely
determine their political status in pursuit of economic, social and cultural
development
|
|
United Nations
Members are “nation states”
|
|
Peoples
|
|
|
Nation
|
Common descendent,
history, culture language
|
|
Nation State
|
Defined by Territorial Boundary
|
|
|
|
Article 3: indigenous peoples possess the right o
self determination including the rights to
·
Shape
public affairs
·
Preserve
identity
·
Promote
development
·
Manage
their own affairs thought self-governing autonomy
Limits on the
right
·
International
law principles include the principle of territorial integrity
·
This
permits nation states to protect and preserve its sovereignty
State determination
·
Even
the best intentioned state determination models must draw the line at indigenous
self government which challenges the territorial integrity and the authority of
that state
·
The
indigenous interest is of necessity relegated to a position behind the larger “national
interest”
National interest
·
Actually
represents the interest of the most politically powerful groups.
·
The
problem is that these larger political interest exist, at least in part as a consequence
of the colonial system and are therefore open to challenges of their legitimacy
by indigenous peoples
·
In
the end indigenous peoples are allowed certain aspects of control of their own affairs,
as long as they do not challenge the ultimate authority of the state (and the larger
political interests)
A New approach?
·
Recognition
of distinctive world view of indigenous peoples
·
Incorporation
of that world view into the partnership of indigenous peoples and the state
·
Recognizing
the right of indigenous peoples to make decisions for themselves as a people.

No comments:
Post a Comment